Lies, damn lies and statistics

Author(s)
Published on
November 8, 2010

So, I'm already running into some challenging snags.

A California transplant, I'm still learning about all the ramifications of Prop 13. Coming from Texas, where school district's still raise money the old fashion way, I mistakenly thought the poorest neighborhoods in the Coachella Valley would have the largest class sizes and the smallest per pupil spending.

Boy was I wrong.

You might wonder what this has to do with the health story I pitched for the California Health Journalism Fellowship, but you'll just have to keep reading

The poorest areas here, thanks largely to Title I funding, actually have the smallest classrooms and the greatest per pupil spending.

The online comments are already ringing in my ears: "See, throwing money at the problem doesn't work."

But I know just enough about the historic disparities that plague the poor and minorities to know that sometimes the numbers are just what my J-school professors said when they warned about the three kinds of lies: lies, damn lies and statistics.

As one education advocate suggests, the even playing field that morphs into a distinct disadvantage for minority children may require more be done with more, not less.