Skip to main content.

Medical Board Files More Charges Against Conrad Murray in Michael Jackson Death

Medical Board Files More Charges Against Conrad Murray in Michael Jackson Death

Picture of William Heisel
Courtesy of lwpkommunikacio

With Justin Bieber ticketed for dodging paparazzi and Katie Holmes awarded primary custody, the gossip press can be forgiven for missing the latest in the case of the doctor who overdosed Michael Jackson.

Conrad Murray has been slapped with a new round of allegations from the Medical Board of California. The timing may seem odd. Jackson died in June 2009, after taking anesthesia drugs prescribed and administered by Murray. Murray was convicted of involuntary manslaughter and sentenced to four years in prison in November 2011. The medical board filed its first round of charges against Murray in February 2012. This new amended accusation is dated June 27, 2012.

In the accusation against Murray filed in February, there were two causes for action: conviction of a crime and failure to maintain adequate records. As I wrote at the time, the document seemed like fill-in-the-blank boilerplate, with more space devoted to the state code Murray violated than the details of the violations.

The amended accusation still includes the conviction and records violations, but it adds “gross negligence-inappropriate administration of dangerous drugs,” “repeated negligent acts-inappropriate administration of dangerous drugs,” and “incompetence-inappropriate administration of dangerous drugs.”

The new charges are much more detailed and provide a full explanation of just how far Murray strayed outside the standards of practice when administering the anesthetic propofol – and other drugs – to Jackson. It breaks down the “gross negligence” violation into four parts. Here are quotes from each:

Excessive administration of dangerous drugs/sedatives:

Propofol is not indicated for the induction of sleep and/or to treat insomnia. It is strictly indicated for moderate or deep sedation in a monitored hospital setting, or an accredited outpatient facility that meets the requirements set forth in Health and Safety Code sections 1248.1 and 1248.15. … [Murray] used dangerous drugs to sedate patient M.J. at his home for the purpose of inducing sleep. On more than 40 occasions between April 2009 and June 25, 2009, patient M.J. was sedated with a combination of benzodiazepines and propofol.

Inadequate monitoring:

The patient is required to have a continuous oxygen delivery system, continuous cardiac monitoring, a continuous intravenous access line established, continuous pulse oximetry monitoring, and continuous blood pressure monitoring, all with audible alert systems. In addition, the following operable equipment is necessary in the room and must be ready for use: oxygen, suction, oral and nasopharyngeal airways, a crash cart with backboard, appropriate emergency resuscitation drugs, and a defibrillator. … [Murray’s] failure to secure appropriate equipment for patient monitoring and his failure to maintain emergency equipment and medications is an extreme departure from the standard of care. Furthermore, no competent physician or surgeon would sedate a patient without ensuring that the appropriate patient monitoring and equipment is readily available.

Failure to maintain medical records:

When a patient is administered medications for sedation and/or anesthesia the standard of care requires that the physician maintain medical records detailing the care rendered to the patient. Documentation of sedation and anesthesia is required for the provision of good medical care and quality assurance.

The board sums it up this way:

[Murray] failed to appropriately monitor patient M.J. He abandoned his patient by leaving M.J. unattended while he was under the influence of heavy sedatives. In addition, he administered propofol and other dangerous drugs to patient M.J. in a home setting without appropriate medical equipment and staff to monitor the maintenance of patient M.J.’s hemodynamics, and did not continuously monitor the patient’s vital signs.

All of this happened in June 2009. Since that time, Murray has been tried, convicted and sent to prison. Murray’s medical license was suspended in Texas and has been allowed to expire in Nevada and Hawaii. Yet, the California medical board is still months – if not years – away from revoking Murray’s license, assuming it does not end up in some settlement agreement with him. It’s still in the charging phase, while the criminal prosecutors and other state boards have gone all the way through the process and moved on.

In March, after the board made its first accusation against Murray, I asked the board’s Director of Public Affairs, Dan Wood, what took so long. He said that the board was waiting for the criminal proceedings to finish before filing charges. He wrote:

To put it in simple terms, once a door is closed and locked no matter who closed and locked it, to rush to repeat the action is redundant. Basically our action now will be the equivalent of placing a sign on the door saying, “This door is now closed and locked officially.”

I wrote him this week to ask whether the door was now being reopened and, if so, what the board hoped to accomplish. I’ll let you know if he responds.

Photo courtesy of Lwp Kommunikáció via Flickr.

Comments

Picture of

Thank you!

Picture of

Dear Mr. Heisel,
Thank you for the update re the ongoing case being brought against Dr. Murray by the Medical Board. Your writing is detailed and well written. While I believe this particular case is well documented, it's not always done with clear cut language, often leaning heavily on the commentary of a gossip publication. I would like to think that the untimely death of Michael Jackson, together with the specific cause on June 25th, and also the circumstances leading up to it, will allow for a world-wide discussion of prevention~ on so many levels I couldn't list each here. We must heal the wounded spirits, no matter how daunting the task and better equip the physicians with tools they need to honor the oath they swore to keep. In my mind, the education the public receives about this and a host of other connected issues, often begins with those writing about it. Integrity is paramount. I look forward to your written words. Thank you.

Picture of

Your opening statement is totally inappropriate and revolting. "With Justin Bieber ticketed for dodging paparazzi and Katie Holmes awarded primary custody, the gossip press can be forgiven for missing the latest in the case of the doctor who overdosed Michael Jackson." This is a despicable way to discuss a senseless homicide. Remove immediately.

Picture of

Very good I hope it goes over well for the State CA.

Picture of

I would never forgive the press for not reporting on the crimes of Conrad Murray, the man responsible for Michael Jackson's death. The press wants to ignore the Murray's role entirely and should not.

Picture of

I would like to thank you, Mr. Heisel, for highlighting in your article Murray's irresponsible actions which caused the death of his patient. It cannot be forgotten. And, hopefully Murray will never forget it and that is never in a position to harm another human being again.

Picture of

Thank you Mr. Heisel for this update. Murray really hung himself! I think the money he was getting paid had him blindsided to reality. By the sounds of it Murray isn't going to be able to practice anywhere. His reputation is ruined as a doctor. I also think Murray didn't realize, it just didn't ever sink in, how huge, popular and loved Michael is. I still don't think Murray gets it. One part of the trial that really sticks out to me is when the judge reprimanded him about his lack of compassion. Thank again Mr. Heisel.

Picture of

Thank you Mr. Heisel for this update. Murray really hung himself! I think the money he was getting paid had him blindsided to reality. By the sounds of it Murray isn't going to be able to practice anywhere. His reputation is ruined as a doctor. I also think Murray didn't realize, it just didn't ever sink in, how huge, popular and loved Michael is. I still don't think Murray gets it. One part of the trial that really sticks out to me is when the judge reprimanded him about his lack of compassion. Thank again Mr. Heisel.

Picture of

So far the USA have treated Conrad Murray with kid gloves; babied him to the utmost and will probably still let him off despite the extra charges! He's protected in jail; given his own room; not put in the main part of the jail; has whined constantly to which the staff at the jail see fit to pander to his every whim and due to get out next year sometime! Some "justice" for Michael and his beloved children!! :-/

Picture of

I agree with the comment made regarding despicable journalistic practice. There was no reason to begin your article with Justin Bieber dodging paparazzi and Katie Holmes getting custody of Surie. I felt it was very inappropriate and cold. We are talking about a senseless murder committed by a so-called doctor.

I also agree with the person who stated that Murray is being treated with kid gloves. I would like to know why he is being kept from the general prison population. Do these people not see that this man committed murder! Our laws here in the U.S. leave much to be desired. Something is definitely wrong when a murderer is pampered and officers of the Court are bending to his every wish.

Leave A Comment

Announcements

Medicare Advantage plans are surging in popularity. What’s at stake for seniors in your community as private companies increasingly administer Medicare? This webinar will help cover an essential story on a program that covers 60 million Americans across the country. Sign-up here!

In this season of giving, you can support journalism that saves lives by making a tax-deductible contribution to the Center for Health Journalism. For 15 years, the Center has made it possible for reporters to call attention to untold stories, highlight solutions and bring communities together around common aims. In today’s difficult news environment, the USC Annenberg Center for Health Journalism provides critical support so that reporters can produce ambitious, game-changing projects on health and well-being. You can text to donate. No amount is too small; just send a text to 41-444 and type the message CHJ for further instructions.

Got a great idea for a substantive reporting project?  Let us fund it! (And bring you to L.A. for five days of intensive training as well!)

CONNECT WITH THE COMMUNITY

Follow Us

Facebook


Twitter

CHJ Icon
ReportingHealth